 | The Friendly (2024) as Cal |
 | Once More, Like Rain Man (2024) as Director 1 |
 | National Memorial Day Concert (2023) as Self |
 | The Last Band on Stage (2022) as Self (Narrator) |
 | The Simpsons: A Serious Flanders (2021) as Fat Tony (voice) |
 | Stallone: Frank, That Is (2021) as Self |
 | Sound the Bells: A Holiday Celebration (2020) as Host |
 | The Godfather, Coda: The Death of Michael Corleone (2020) as Joey Zasa |
 | Cool Cat's Crazy Dream (2019) as Dream World Joe |
 | Davi's Way (2018) as Self |
 | 20 (2018) as Self |
 | The Bronx Bull (2016) as Rick Rosselli |
 | Now More than Ever: The History of Chicago (2016) as Self |
 | Childless (2015) as Richard |
 | Kill Me, Deadly (2015) as Bugsy Siegel |
 | 10 Cent Pistol (2014) as Punchy |
 | Compulsion (2013) as Detective Reynolds |
 | Say It Ain't Solo (2012) as Self |
 | The War of 1812 (2011) as Narrator |
 | Cars 2 (2011) as Grem (voice) |
 | Chicago Cubs: The Heart and Soul of Chicago (2011) as Self |
 | Off The Boulevard (2011) |
| | Hannah Mantegna (2010) as Hannah Mantegna |
 | Valentine's Day (2010) as Angry Driver (uncredited) |
 | The Simpsons 20th Anniversary Special - In 3D! On Ice! (2010) as Self |
 | Starz Inside - Unforgettably Evil (2009) as Self |
 | The Assistants (2009) as Gary Greene |
 | The House That Jack Built (2009) as Jack Jr. |
 | My Suicide (2009) as Dr. Chandrasakar |
 | Lonely Street (2009) as Jerry Finkelman |
 | The Masterpiece That Almost Wasn't (2008) as Self |
 | Redbelt (2008) as Jerry Weiss |
 | The Last Hit Man (2008) as Harry Tremayne |
 | Justice League: The New Frontier (2008) as Crooner (voice) |
 | Witless Protection (2008) as Dr. Rondog 'Doc' Savage |
 | West of Brooklyn (2008) as Gaetano D'Amico |
| | WooLife (2008) as Joe Mantegna |
 | Hank and Mike (2008) as Mr. Pan |
 | Stories USA (2007) as Mike (segment "Club Soda") |
 | Heckler (2007) as Self |
 | The Simpsons Movie (2007) as Fat Tony (voice) |
 | Cougar Club (2007) as Mr. Stack |
 | Saturday Night Live in the '90s: Pop Culture Nation (2007) as Self |
 | Naked Fear (2007) as Tom Benike |
 | Chasing October (2007) as Self |
 | Elvis & Anabelle (2007) as Charlie Moreau |
| | Cheat You Fair: The Story of Maxwell Street (2006) as Narrator |
 | Club Soda (2006) as Mike |
 | Edmond (2006) as Man in Bar |
 | The Best of The Tony Awards: The Plays (2006) as Bobby Gould (segment "Speed-the-Plow") |
 | The Kid & I (2005) as Davis Roman |
 | Nine Lives (2005) as Richard |
 | A Very Married Christmas (2004) as Frank Griffin |
 | Elf: Christmas in Tinseltown (2004) as Self |
 | This Old Cub (2004) as Narrator |
 | Stateside (2004) as Gil Deloach |
 | Pontormo - Un amore eretico (2004) as Pontormo |
 | Uncle Nino (2003) as Robert Micelli |
 | Comedy Central Roast of Denis Leary (2003) as Self |
 | Mother Ghost (2002) as Jerry Savior |
 | Women vs. Men (2002) as Michael |
 | I Was a Teenage Faust (2002) as Himself |
 | Off Key (2001) as Ricardo Palacios |
 | Walking Shadow (2001) as Spenser |
 | Turbulence 3: Heavy Metal (2001) as Frank Garner |
 | The Trumpet of the Swan (2001) as Monty (voice) |
 | Laguna (2001) as Nicola Pianon |
 | Fall (2001) as Agent Jim Danaher |
 | Thin Air (2000) as Spenser |
 | Body and Soul (2000) as Alex Dumas |
 | More Dogs Than Bones (2000) as Desalvo |
 | Lakeboat (2000) as Man at Gate (uncredited) |
 | Liberty Heights (1999) as Nate Kurtzman |
 | My Little Assassin (1999) as Fidel Castro |
 | The Runner (1999) as Rocco |
 | Small Vices (1999) as Spenser |
 | Error in Judgment (1999) as Eric |
 | Jerry and Tom (1998) as Tom |
 | Celebrity (1998) as Tony Gardella |
 | Boy Meets Girl (1998) as Il Magnifico |
 | The Rat Pack (1998) as Dean Martin |
 | Airspeed (1998) as Raymond Stone |
 | Hoods (1998) as Angelo Martinelli |
 | The Great Empire: Rome (1998) as Narrateur |
 | The Wonderful Ice Cream Suit (1998) as Gomez |
 | Merry Christmas, George Bailey (1997) as Joseph / Nick |
 | Face Down (1997) as Bob Signorelli |
 | For Hire (1997) as Alan Webber |
 | A Call to Remember (1997) as David Tobias |
 | Albino Alligator (1997) as A.T.F. Agent G.D. Browning |
 | Persons Unknown (1996) as Jim Holland |
 | Thinner (1996) as Richie Ginelli |
 | Underworld (1996) as Frank Gavilan / Frank Cassady / Richard Essex |
 | Up Close & Personal (1996) as Bucky Terranova |
 | Blacklist: Hollywood on Trial (1996) as Mark Goodson |
 | Eye for an Eye (1996) as Detective Sergeant Denillo |
| | Cigars!: The New Rage! (1996) as Self |
 | National Lampoon's Favorite Deadly Sins (1995) as Frank Musso |
 | Captain Nuke and the Bomber Boys (1995) as Joey Franelli |
 | Above Suspicion (1995) as Alan Rhinehart |
 | Forget Paris (1995) as Andy |
 | For Better or Worse (1995) as Stone |
 | Airheads (1994) as Ian |
 | Baby's Day Out (1994) as Eddie |
 | State of Emergency (1994) as Dr John Novelli |
 | Searching for Bobby Fischer (1993) as Fred Waitzkin |
 | Family Prayers (1993) as Martin Jacobs |
 | Body of Evidence (1993) as Robert Garrett |
 | The Godfather Trilogy: 1901-1980 (1992) as Joey Zasa |
 | The Water Engine (1992) as Lawrence Oberman |
 | When It Was a Game 2 (1992) as Passage Narrator (voice) |
 | The Comrades of Summer (1992) as Sparky |
 | Bugsy (1991) as George Raft |
 | Death on the Job (1991) as Narrator |
 | Homicide (1991) as Bob Gold |
 | Queens Logic (1991) as Al |
 | Alice (1990) as Joe |
 | The Godfather Part III (1990) as Joey Zasa |
 | The Godfather Family: A Look Inside (1990) as Self / Joey Zasa |
 | Wait Until Spring, Bandini (1989) as Bandini |
| | Crack USA: County Under Siege (1989) as Narrator |
 | Things Change (1988) as Jerry |
 | Suspect (1987) as Charlie Stella |
 | Weeds (1987) as Carmine |
 | House of Games (1987) as Mike |
 | Critical Condition (1987) as Arthur Chambers |
 | ¡Three Amigos! (1986) as Harry Flugleman |
 | Off Beat (1986) as Pete Peterson |
 | The Money Pit (1986) as Art Shirk |
 | Compromising Positions (1985) as Bruce Fleckstein |
 | The Outlaws (1984) as Yuri |
| | Cannonball! (1984) |
 | Second Thoughts (1983) |
 | The Remarkable Riderless Runaway Tricycle (1982) as customer |
 | Bleacher Bums (1979) as Decker |
 | Elvis (1979) as Joe Esposito |
 | Towing (1978) as Chris |
 | Assassins (1978) as Mullani |
 | Main Street Eagle (1976) |
 | Medusa Challenger (1976) |
 | Midnight Men: A John Schlesinger and Michael Childers Story |
 | Bleacher Bums Theatre Play |
| | Lakeboat Director |
| | Lakeboat Producer |
 | Corduroy Executive Producer |
| | Corduroy Producer |
| | The Remarkable Riderless Runaway Tricycle Production Assistant |
| | Bleacher Bums Writer |
