Trailer
 | Christopher Brian as Tim Schmidt |
 | Quinn Nehr as Bobby Sanders |
| Cory Cunningham as Mr. O |
 | Anastasia Mirabelle as Sarah Jennings |
| Liana Marie Zaino as Becky Dickson |
| Dylan Toms as Bert Williston |
| Branden E. Murphy as Pig (as Branden Murphy) |
 | Tony Wood as Ricky Schmidt |
 | Stuart Maxheimer as Arnie |
| Careem Joy as Sean |
 | Nicholas Runfolo as Sam |
| Barbara Zablocky as Fran Schmidt |
| Phillip D. Bauer as Fred Schmidt |
 | Danielle J. Bowman as Betsy Jennings |
| Rahmein Mostafavi as Daniel Jennings |
| Ethan Riffle as Billy Jennings |
| Kevin Joel Anderson as Mr. Borfman |
| Grant Raska as George |
 | John Capocci as Gramps |
| Matthew Sharpe as Lyle Lunders |
 | Matthew Sharpe as Principal Tillman |
| Allen McRae as Ambassador Sanders |
| Kathie Pepper as Mrs. Sanders |
| Daniel Stonewall as Sonny |
| Conor Patrick Donahue as Mario |
| Andreas Chris as Kid in Halloween Bandit Costume and Graduation |
| Camilo Eraso as Ferdinand |
| Madison Grace Smith as Shannon |
| Rahul Gajasamharamoorthy as Santo Klaus |
| Susan Scher as Grandma |
| Collin Hendley as English students asking 'Rumple?' |
| Kimberly Basha as Ms. Sloan |
| Taikirha Miller as Cheerleader #1 |
| Kiara M. Carter as Cheerleader #2 |
| J. Randell Minchew as President Kinkaide |
| Sophie de Waal as George's Friend #1 |
| Eli Gay as George's Friend #2 |
| Trevor Stevie Ray Ontiveros as Home Plate Umpire |
| Michael A. Short as First Base Umpire |
| Victoria Stephenson as Charlene |
| Nina Men as Wendy |
| Olivia Mayhew Hays as Tracy |
| Khawaja Aziz as Mr. Jones |
| Libby York as First Baseman on Jones' Team |
| Quincy Redmon as Menacing Batter on Jones' Team |
| Christian A. Payne as Third Baseman on Jones' Team |
| Abdul Quadir Yussuf as First Batter on Jones' Team |
| Daniel Campos as Pitcher on Jones' Team |
| Angus McAllister as Catcher on Jones' Team |
| David Giovanni as Hallway Bully |
| Brandon Keeton as Policeman #1 |
 | Crayton Spade as Policeman #2 |
| Ali Cheff as Messenger in Physics Class |
| Kendall Felix as Sarah's Halloween Friend |
| Trey Jordan as Halloween Popcorn Guy |
| Evelyn Logan as Graduation School Official #1 |
| Lawrence R. Daniels as Graduation School Official #2 |
| Darryl Franklin Jr. as Students in English Class |
| Khalil I. Franklin as Students in English Class |
| Naseem X. Franklin as Students in English Class |
| Max Harris as Bartender |
| Dan Verkman as High School Graduation Attendee |
| Genevieve Howley as Right Fielder (uncredited) |
| Alena Marie as Holiday Party Guest (uncredited) |
| Sofiah Marie as Holiday Party Guest (uncredited) |
| Crew | |
| Jeremy Royce | Cinematography |
Costume & Make-Up | |
| Sara Ritmiller | Key Makeup Artist |
Art | |
| Max Harris | Assistant Art Director |
Visual Effects | |
| Henry Torbin | Visual Effects |
Art | |
| Stephanie Jeandell | Assistant Art Director |
Sound | |
| Elton Ahi | Music Sound Design and Processing |
| Randy Edelman | Music |
Production | |
| Carlos Chavez | Production Assistant |
Art | |
| Trevor Stevie Ray Ontiveros | Property Master |
Lighting | |
| Jesse Hosick | Best Boy Electric |
Art | |
| Kat Manchester | Set Decoration |
Costume & Make-Up | |
| Taylor Gray Burke | Key Costumer |
Sound | |
| Christian Velasco-Mills | Songs |
Production | |
| Hailey Lood | Production Assistant |
| Saadeh P.C. | Consulting Producer |
Editing | |
| Tony Malanowski | Editor |
Sound | |
| Sebastian Levy Polat | Sound Mixer |
Visual Effects | |
| Brian DeMetz | Visual Effects |
Production | |
| Evelyn Manchester | Additional Casting |
Editing | |
| Taylor Doose | Assistant Editor |
Sound | |
| Peter Mullen | Supervising Sound Editor |
Directing | |
| Patricia Meyers | First Assistant Director |
Art | |
| Catherine Harris | Assistant Art Director |
Camera | |
| Briana Del Giorno | First Assistant Camera |
| Sam Grodnitzky | Key Grip |
Production | |
| Gregg Harris | Executive Producer |
Camera | |
| Maddy Wade | Second Assistant Camera |
Crew | |
| Aditya Ezhuthachan | Legal Services |
Visual Effects | |
| Emad N. Al-Khateeb | Visual Effects |
Lighting | |
| James A. Ray | Gaffer |
Directing | |
| Kat Manchester | Script Supervisor |
| Tirzah Shepard | Script Supervisor |
Lighting | |
| Hannah Cantrell | Other |
Crew | |
| David Albert Pierce | Legal Services |
Sound | |
| Caitlyn Mason | Boom Operator |
Camera | |
| Noah Vickers | Second Assistant Camera |
Production | |
| Bryan Steger | Production Assistant |
Camera | |
| Nathan Airey | Best Boy Grip |
Crew | |
| Cathie Saadeh | Legal Services |
Sound | |
| John Velasco | Music Supervisor |
Costume & Make-Up | |
| Doris Elias | Makeup Artist |
Directing | |
| Evelyn Manchester | Second Assistant Director |
Sound | |
| Joshua Eli Roberts | Boom Operator |
Writing | |
| Gregg Harris | Writer |
Production | |
| Marisa Whitcomb | Production Assistant |
Directing | |
| Gregg Harris | Director |
