 | The Gettysburg Address (2025) as William Saunders (voice) |
 | You Had to Be There: How the Toronto Godspell Ignited the Comedy Revolution... (2025) as Self / Jesus |
 | John Candy: I Like Me (2025) as Self - Actor (archive footage) |
 | Relay (2025) as McVie |
 | Heritage Minutes: Bora Laskin (2025) as Bora Laskin |
 | Broadway's Leading Men: A Musical Celebration (2024) as Self |
 | Fly Me to the Moon (2024) as Senator Hedges (uncredited) |
 | Titanic: Stories from the Heart (2023) as Self (archive footage) |
 | Wish (2023) as Sabino (voice) |
 | Cinderella: The Reunion, A Special Edition of 20/20 (2022) as Self |
 | Beebo Saves Christmas (2021) as Narrator |
 | Heritage Minutes: The Discovery of Insulin (2021) as Narrator (voice) |
 | Funny Face (2021) as Developer's Father |
 | Laura Ingalls Wilder: Prairie to Page (2020) as Narrator |
 | Happiest Season (2020) as Ted |
 | Dark Waters (2019) as Phil Donnelly |
 | The Woman Who Loves Giraffes (2018) as Alex Matthew (voice) |
 | They Shall Not Perish: The Story of Near East Relief (2017) as Narrator |
 | Rebel in the Rye (2017) as Sol Salinger |
 | Vixen: The Movie (2017) as Dr. Martin Stein / Firestorm (voice) |
 | Tom Hanks: A League of His Own (2016) as Self |
 | Bob's Broken Sleigh (2015) as Fluffy (voice) |
 | Sicario (2015) as Dave Jennings |
 | Self/less (2015) as Martin |
 | Consumed (2015) as Dan Conway |
 | Big Game (2014) as Vice President |
 | The Hunters (2013) as Mason Fuller |
 | I'll Follow You Down (2013) as Sal |
 | Argo (2012) as Ken Taylor |
 | Reflections on Titanic (2012) as Self |
 | Moving Day (2012) as Wilf |
 | William & Catherine: A Royal Romance (2012) as HRH Prince Charles |
 | The Entitled (2011) as Bob Vincent |
| | Rebuilding Titanic (2011) as Narrator (voice) |
 | Kung Fu Panda 2 (2011) as Master Thundering Rhino (voice) |
 | Take Me Home (2011) as Arnold Colvin |
 | Ice Quake (2010) as Colonel Bill Hughes |
 | You Again (2010) as Mark |
 | The Town (2010) as Assistant Bank Manager (uncredited) |
 | Green Lantern: First Flight (2009) as Sinestro (voice) |
 | Waking the Baby Mammoth (2009) as Narrator |
 | Augustus Saint-Gaudens: Master of American Sculpture (2009) as Narrator |
 | Milk (2008) as Mayor Moscone |
 | The Best of The Tony Awards: The Plays (2006) as Max (segment "Lend Me a Tenor") |
 | ABC's 50th Anniversary Celebration (2003) as Self - Jack Bristow |
 | The Music Man (2003) as Mayor Shinn |
 | Tuck Everlasting (2002) as Robert Foster |
 | Home Room (2002) as Det. martin Van Zandt |
 | Torso: The Evelyn Dick Story (2002) as J.J. Robinette |
 | Call Me Claus (2001) as Taylor |
 | Legally Blonde (2001) as Professor Callahan |
 | A Colder Kind of Death (2001) as Insp. Philip Millard |
 | The Wandering Soul Murders (2001) as Insp. Philip Millard |
 | Deadly Appearances (2000) as Inspector Philip Millard |
 | Love and Murder (2000) as Inspector Philip Millard |
 | Boys Briefs (1999) as Father Carson (segment "The Absolution of Anthony") |
 | Annie (1999) as Oliver Warbucks |
 | Invisible Child (1999) as Tim Beeman |
 | Summer's End (1999) as Narrator (voice) |
 | Beyond Titanic (1998) as Narrator |
 | How Stella Got Her Groove Back (1998) as Isaac (uncredited) |
 | Titanic (1997) as Thomas Andrews |
 | Cinderella (1997) as King Maximillian |
 | Let Me Call You Sweetheart (1997) as Geoff Dorso |
 | The Absolution of Anthony (1997) as Father Carson |
 | The First Wives Club (1996) as Bill Atchison |
 | Hostile Advances: The Kerry Ellison Story (1996) as Jack Gilcrest |
 | Jeffrey (1995) as Tim |
 | Kleptomania (1995) as Morgan Allen |
 | Mixed Nuts (1994) as Irate Neighbor (voice) |
 | Exotica (1994) as Harold |
 | Dieppe (1993) as Lord Louis Mountbatten |
| | Friends of Gilda (1993) as Self |
 | Sleepless in Seattle (1993) as Greg |
 | Life with Mikey (1993) as Brian Spiro |
 | Woman on Trial: The Lawrencia Bembenek Story (1993) as Frank Marrocco |
 | I'll Never Get to Heaven (1993) as Eric Hoskins |
 | Singles (1992) as Kid's Dad |
 | Light Sleeper (1992) as Tis Brooke |
 | Sondheim: A Celebration at Carnegie Hall (1992) as Self |
| | Walking the Dog (1992) |
 | The First Circle (1992) as Lew Rubin |
 | Grand Larceny (1991) as Judge Keeler |
 | Liberace: Behind the Music (1988) as Liberace |
 | The Legendary Life of Ernest Hemingway (1988) as Ernest Hemingway |
 | Roanoak (1986) as John White |
 | Private Sessions (1985) as Jerry Sharma |
 | Charley's Aunt (1983) as Jack Chesney |
 | Tartuffe (1978) as Valere |
 | Ah, Wilderness! (1976) as Arthur |
 | Valley Forge (1975) as Gen. Fafayette |
 | Monkeys in the Attic (1974) as Eric |
 | Cyrano (1974) as Christian de Neuvillette (voice) |
 | Godspell (1973) as Jesus |
| | Kill the Poet |
| | Eloise |
 | Let It Kill You as Pastor John |
