| The Bride! (2026) as Clyde |
| Omaha (2025) as Dad |
| The Mastermind (2025) as Fred |
| Materialists (2025) as Mark P. (voice) |
| Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer (2025) as Keane |
| Köln 75 (2025) as Keith Jarrett |
| Day of the Fight (2024) as Patrick |
| September 5 (2024) as Geoffrey Mason |
| LaRoy, Texas (2024) as Ray |
| Under the Boardwalk (2023) as Manny (voice) |
| The Mistress (2023) as Parker |
| Past Lives (2023) as Arthur |
| Big George Foreman (2023) as Desmond |
| Showing Up (2023) as Sean |
| Call Jane (2022) as Detective Chilmark |
| 18½ (2022) as Paul |
| The Many Saints of Newark (2021) as Silvio Dante |
| Lansky (2021) as Young Meyer Lansky |
| The Birthday Cake (2021) as Cousin Joey |
| First Cow: A Place in This World (2020) as Self |
| First Cow (2020) as Cookie |
| Sylvie's Love (2020) as Sid |
| Gone Hollywood (2019) as Eli Zeller |
| Overlord (2018) as Tibbet |
| Marshall (2017) as Irwin Friedman |
| War Machine (2017) as Cory Staggart |
| Don't Worry Baby (2016) as Robert Lang |
| The Finest Hours (2016) as Ervin Maske |
| The Big Short (2015) as Charlie Geller |
| Carol (2015) as Dannie McElroy |
| Unbroken (2014) as Frank A. Tinker |
| Deep Powder (2013) as Cota |
| Not Fade Away (2012) as Douglas Damiano |
| Liberal Arts (2012) as Dean |
| Down the Shore (2011) as Martin |
| My Soul to Take (2010) as Alex |
| The Box (2009) as Charles |
| Taking Chance (2009) as Rich Brewer |
| Assassination of a High School President (2008) as Cipriato |
| The Brave One (2007) as Ethan |
| The Life Before Her Eyes (2007) as Michael Patrick |
| Bomb (2007) |
| Psycho Therapy: The Shallow Tale of a Writer Who Decided to Write About a Serial Killer Executive Producer |
| Köln 75 Associate Producer |
| Tender Producer |
| Silk Director |