| Coded: The Hidden Love of J.C. Leyendecker (2021) as Archival Footage |
| Synthwave Horror: Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (2015) as Dr. Henry Jekyll / Mr. Edward Hyde |
| Irving Thalberg: Prince of Hollywood (2005) as Self (archive footage) |
| Checking Out: Grand Hotel (2004) as Self / Various roles (archive footage) |
| Complicated Women (2003) as Self (archive footage) |
| The Casting Couch (1995) |
| 100 Years at the Movies (1994) as Self (archive footage) |
| Empire of the Air: The Men Who Made Radio (1991) as Hamlet (archive sound) |
| Going Hollywood: The '30s (1984) as (archive footage) |
| The Horror of It All (1983) as Svengali (archive footage) |
| The Horror Show (1979) as (archive footage) |
| That's Entertainment, Part II (1976) as (archive footage) |
| It's Showtime (1976) as Self (archive footage) |
| The Horror Hall of Fame: A Monster Salute (1974) as Self (archive footage) |
| Hollywood: The Dream Factory (1972) as Self (archive footage) |
| Brasileiros em Hollywood (1970) as Self (archive footage) |
| The Legend of Rudolph Valentino (1961) as Self (archive footage) |
| Yesterday and Today (1953) as (archive footage) |
| The Golden Twenties (1950) as Self (archive footage) |
| Okay for Sound (1946) as Don Juan (archive footage) |
| Screen Snapshots (Series 25, No. 1): 25th Anniversary (1945) as Self (archive footage) |
| The Voice That Thrilled the World (1943) as Self (segments 'Don Juan' & 'Richard III') (archive footage) |
| Screen Snapshots (Series 22, No. 10) (1942) as Self (archive footage) |
| Playmates (1941) as John Barrymore |
| World Premiere (1941) as Duncan DeGrasse |
| The Invisible Woman (1940) as Professor Gibbs |
| The Great Profile (1940) as Evans Garrick |
| Land of Liberty (1939) as (archive footage) |
| The Green Goddess (1939) |
| Midnight (1939) as Georges Flammarion |
| The Great Man Votes (1939) as Vance |
| Hold That Co-ed (1938) as Gabby Harrigan |
| Spawn of the North (1938) as Windy Turlon |
| Marie Antoinette (1938) as King Louis XV |
| Hollywood Goes to Town (1938) as Self |
| Romance in the Dark (1938) as Zoltan Jason |
| Bulldog Drummond's Peril (1938) as Colonel Neilson |
| True Confession (1937) as Charles Jasper |
| Bulldog Drummond's Revenge (1937) as Col. J.A. Nielson |
| Night Club Scandal (1937) as Dr. Ernest Tindal |
| Bulldog Drummond Comes Back (1937) as Colonel Neilson |
| Maytime (1937) as Nicolai Nazaroff |
| Romeo and Juliet (1936) as Mercutio |
| Movie Maniacs (1936) as Photograph of John Barrymore (uncredited) |
| Twentieth Century (1934) as Oscar Jaffe |
| Long Lost Father (1934) as Carl Bellairs |
| Counsellor at Law (1933) as George Simon |
| Dinner at Eight (1933) as Larry Renault |
| Night Flight (1933) as Riviere |
| Reunion in Vienna (1933) as Archduke Rudolf von Hapsburg |
| Hamlet, Act I: Scenes IV and V (1933) as Hamlet |
| Topaze (1933) as Auguste A. Topaze |
| Rasputin and the Empress (1932) as Prince Paul Chegodieff |
| A Bill of Divorcement (1932) as Hilary Fairfield |
| Grand Hotel (1932) as Baron Felix von Gaigern |
| State's Attorney (1932) as Tom Cardigan |
| Arsène Lupin (1932) as Duke of Charmerace |
| The Mad Genius (1931) as Vladimar Ivan Tsarakov |
| Svengali (1931) as Svengali |
| Moby Dick (1930) as Ahab |
| The Man from Blankley's (1930) as Lord Strathpeffer |
| General Crack (1929) as Duke of Kurland / Prince Christian |
| The Show of Shows (1929) as Richard III in 'Henry VI Part III' (uncredited) |
| Eternal Love (1929) as Marcus Paltran |
| Tempest (1928) as Sergeant Ivan Markov |
| The Circus: Premiere (1928) as Self |
| Life in Hollywood No. 4 (1927) |
| When a Man Loves (1927) as Chevalier Fabien des Grieux |
| The Beloved Rogue (1927) as François Villon |
| Don Juan (1926) as Don Jose de Marana / Don Juan de Marana |
| The Sea Beast (1926) as Captain Ahab Ceeley |
| Vagabonding On The Pacific (1926) as Himself |
| Ben-Hur: A Tale of the Christ (1925) as Chariot Race Spectator (uncredited) |
| Beau Brummel (1924) as Gordon Bryon 'Beau' Brummel |
| Sherlock Holmes (1922) as Sherlock Holmes |
| The Lotus Eater (1921) as Jacques Leroi |
| Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1920) as Dr. Henry Jekyll / Mr. Edward Hyde |
| The Test of Honor (1919) as Martin Wingrave |
| Here Comes the Bride (1919) as Frederick Tile |
| On the Quiet (1918) as Robert Ridgeway |
| Raffles, the Amateur Cracksman (1917) as A.J. Raffles |
| National Red Cross Pageant (1917) as The Tyrant - Russian episode |
| The Red Widow (1916) as Cicero Hannibal Butts |
| The Lost Bridegroom (1916) as Bertie Joyce |
| Nearly a King (1916) as Jack Merriwell, Prince of Bulwana |
| The Incorrigible Dukane (1915) as James Dukane |
| The Dictator (1915) as Brooke Travers |
| Are You a Mason? (1915) as Frank Perry |
| The Man from Mexico (1914) as Fitzhugh |
| An American Citizen (1914) as Berresford Cruger |
| One on Romance (1913) as Jack Wilson (as Jack Barrymore) |
| A Prize Package (1912) as Si Hawkins (as Jack Barrymore) |
| Just Pretending (1912) as The Policeman (as Jack Barrymore) |
| The Widow Casey's Return (1912) as The Rejected Suitor (as Jack Barrymore) |
| The Dream of a Moving Picture Director (1912) as The Movie Villain (as Jack Barrymore) |