| The Rescue (2027) |
| The Leader (2026) as Marshall Applewhite |
| The Testament of Ann Lee (2025) as Pastor Reuben Wight |
| Die Coen-Brüder - Eine amerikanische Geschichte (2025) as Self |
| Atropia (2025) as Mr. Speaker (voice) |
| On the End (2025) as Tom Ferreira |
| Bang Bang (2025) as Bernard 'Bang Bang' Rozyski |
| Captain America: Brave New World (2025) as Samuel Sterns |
| Greedy People (2024) as Wallace |
| The Invisibles (2024) as Charlie |
| Asleep in My Palm (2024) as Tom |
| The Bricklayer (2023) as O'Malley |
| Ghosted (2023) as Borislov |
| Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio (2022) as Black Rabbits (voice) |
| Ninety-Five Senses (2022) as Coy (voice) |
| Ghosts of the Ozarks (2022) as Torb |
| National Champions (2021) as Rodger Cummings |
| Nightmare Alley (2021) as Carny Boss |
| Old Henry (2021) as Henry |
| Naked Singularity (2021) as Angus |
| Monster (2021) as Leroy Sawicki |
| Sequestrada (2019) as Thomas |
| Just Mercy (2019) as Ralph Myers |
| The Jesus Rolls (2019) as Doctor |
| The True Don Quixote (2019) as Don Quixote |
| The Report (2019) as Raymond Nathan |
| Angel Has Fallen (2019) as VP Kirby |
| Joseph Pulitzer: Voice of the People (2019) as Teddy Roosevelt (voice) |
| The Ballad of Buster Scruggs (2018) as Buster Scruggs (segment "The Ballad of Buster Scruggs") |
| The Vanishing of Sidney Hall (2018) as Johan |
| Wormwood (2017) as Sidney Gottlieb |
| Colossal (2017) as Garth |
| The Institute (2017) as Dr. Lemelle |
| Deidra & Laney Rob a Train (2017) as Truman |
| Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk (2016) as Wayne Foster |
| The Confirmation (2016) as Vaughn |
| Anesthesia (2016) as Adam Zarrow |
| The Sound and the Fury (2015) as Father |
| Fantastic Four (2015) as Dr. Allen |
| Black Dog, Red Dog (2015) as Bob |
| Rickover: The Birth of Nuclear Power (2014) as Admiral Rickover |
| Kill the Messenger (2014) as Alan Fenster |
| The Homesman (2014) as The Freighter |
| Child of God (2014) as Sheriff Fate |
| Misfire: The Rise and Fall of the Shooting Gallery (2013) as Self |
| As I Lay Dying (2013) as Anse |
| Blue Caprice (2013) as Ray |
| Snake & Mongoose (2013) as Mike McAllister |
| Lincoln (2012) as Richard Schell |
| Adventures in the Sin Bin (2012) as Officer Totsch |
| Big Miracle (2012) as Pat Lafaytette |
| The Big Year (2011) as Fuchs |
| Flypaper (2011) as Peanut Butter |
| Detachment (2011) as Mr. Wiatt |
| Yelling To The Sky (2011) as Coleman |
| Saint John of Las Vegas (2010) as Ned |
| Leaves of Grass (2009) as Bolger |
| American Violet (2008) as David Cohen |
| The Incredible Hulk (2008) as Samuel Sterns |
| The Darwin Awards (2007) as Perp |
| The Astronaut Farmer (2007) as Kevin Munchak |
| Hoot (2006) as Curly |
| Fido (2006) as Mr. Theopolis |
| The Amateurs (2006) as Barney |
| Come Early Morning (2006) as Uncle Tim |
| Syriana (2005) as Danny Dalton |
| The Big White (2005) as Gary |
| Warm Springs (2005) as Tom Loyless |
| Crazy for Love (2005) as Doctor, Chief Nakahoma, Minister, Roger Bob |
| Meet the Fockers (2004) as Officer LeFlore |
| The Last Shot (2004) as Marshal Paris |
| Bereft (2004) as Dennis |
| A Foreign Affair (2004) as Jake Adams |
| Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed (2004) as Jacobo |
| Wonderland (2003) as Billy Deverell |
| Holes (2003) as Dr. Pendanski |
| The Good Girl (2002) as Bubba |
| Minority Report (2002) as Gideon |
| Cherish (2002) as Daly |
| Down from the Mountain (2001) as Self |
| The Coen Brothers (2000) as Self |
| O Brother, Where Art Thou? (2000) as Delmar O'Donnell |
| Hamlet (2000) as Flight Captain |
| The Thin Red Line (1998) as Pvt. Brian Tills |
| Prix Fixe (1997) as Busboy |
| Donnie Brasco (1997) as FBI Technician |
| Joe's Apartment (1996) as Cockroach (voice) |
| Heavyweights (1995) as Camp Hope Salesman |
| Amateur (1994) as Young Detective |
| This Is My Life (1992) as Dennis |
| The Life and Deaths of Wilson Shedd |
| The Long Home |
| The Leader Executive Producer |
| Eddington Thanks |
| Asleep in My Palm Producer |
| Anesthesia Director |
| Anesthesia Writer |
| Anesthesia Producer |
| Leaves of Grass Director |
| Leaves of Grass Writer |
| Leaves of Grass Producer |
| Haskett's Chance Director |
| The Grey Zone Director |
| The Grey Zone Writer |
| The Grey Zone Producer |
| The Grey Zone Editor |
| O Director |
| Eye of God Director |
| Eye of God Screenplay |
| Michael Zero Director |
| The Life and Deaths of Wilson Shedd Director |
| The Life and Deaths of Wilson Shedd Writer |
| The Life and Deaths of Wilson Shedd Producer |